So it looks like we have an unexpected event! We have a tie!
DakotaSpine - a chipped leg bone, a hunk of iron ore, and something unmentionable (3)
FrostyPeaches - an ancient vessel, glittery shard, a cracked canine skull, and some lost car keys (4)
lLuminI - a dusty, yellow gem (1)
Melomar - a...